When it comes to building a custom mechanical keyboard, keycaps are an essential part of the experience. The profile of the keycaps—how they are shaped and their height—affects both the aesthetics and feel of typing. Custom keycap profiles come in a variety of shapes, and choosing the right one can make a big difference in your typing experience custom keycaps. In this post, we’ll break down some of the most popular custom keycap profiles, along with their pros and cons.
1. SA Profile
The SA profile is known for its tall, spherical keycaps that have a distinct retro look. These keycaps are a fan favorite for many enthusiasts, especially for their nostalgic appeal.
Pros:
- Unique Aesthetic: The spherical shape and tall height give the keyboard a classic, almost typewriter-like feel.
- Typing Experience: The height of the keys can provide a satisfying typing experience, especially for those who prefer more travel and tactile feedback.
- Customization Options: SA keycaps come in a wide variety of colors and designs, making it easy to create a highly personalized keyboard.
Cons:
- Ergonomics: The tall height of SA keycaps can be uncomfortable for some people, especially during long typing sessions. The keys can feel steep and hard to get used to.
- Learning Curve: Because of their height and shape, they can take some time to adapt to, particularly for those used to lower-profile keys.
- Price: Due to their distinctive shape and manufacturing complexity, SA keycaps tend to be on the expensive side.
2. Cherry Profile
The Cherry profile is perhaps the most iconic and widely used keycap profile. It features a relatively low and uniform shape, making it a popular choice for both gamers and typists alike.
Pros:
- Comfortable and Ergonomic: The Cherry profile is considered to be one of the most comfortable keycap profiles due to its low height and gentle slant across the rows, making it easier on the fingers.
- Typing Speed: The lower profile can help increase typing speed since it requires less finger travel.
- Versatility: It’s a great all-around choice for both gaming and typing, and it works well for people with different typing styles.
Cons:
- Lack of Visual Appeal: While functional, some people find the Cherry profile a bit plain or lacking in character compared to taller profiles like SA or DSA.
- Less Impactful Sound: Due to its shorter height, the acoustics of Cherry keycaps are quieter compared to taller profiles, which can be a downside for those who enjoy louder, more satisfying keystrokes.
3. DSA Profile
The DSA profile is known for its flat, uniform keycaps. Unlike other profiles that have varying heights depending on their row, DSA keycaps are all the same height and shape across the entire board.
Pros:
- Consistency: The uniform height of DSA keycaps creates a consistent feel across the entire board, which some users appreciate for both typing and gaming.
- Ergonomics: Since the keys are flat, they can be more comfortable for those who prefer minimal vertical movement, especially for touch typists.
- Variety: DSA keycaps come in many colors and design options, and their flatness can make them easier to clean and maintain.
Cons:
- Lack of Row Differentiation: Some typists find that the uniformity of DSA keycaps makes it harder to differentiate between rows, potentially leading to inaccurate keystrokes or a less comfortable typing experience.
- Limited Typing Feedback: The flatness of DSA keycaps doesn’t provide as much tactile feedback or “pushback” as taller profiles, which may be a turnoff for users seeking more feedback.
4. OEM Profile
OEM profile keycaps are a common choice for factory-built keyboards, featuring a moderate height with a slight curve and varying heights across the rows.
Pros:
- Familiarity: OEM keycaps are often pre-installed on many keyboards, meaning most users are already familiar with their feel and layout.
- Comfortable Typing Experience: The varying heights of the keys are designed to provide a natural and ergonomic typing experience, with a slight curve to each row to match the natural movement of the fingers.
- Affordability: OEM keycaps are typically more affordable than other custom profiles, making them a great entry-level choice for those just starting with mechanical keyboards.
Cons:
- Standard Look: While comfortable, the OEM profile doesn’t stand out visually, and many users see it as too generic.
- Lesser Customization: Because they are the default profile on many keyboards, there’s less opportunity for customization compared to profiles like SA or Cherry.
5. Kailh Box Profile
Kailh Box keycaps are another popular option, typically featuring a slightly higher profile with a square top and crisp edges. These are often paired with Kailh Box switches, which add to their unique feel.
Pros:
- Distinctive Look: The square edges and unique profile give Kailh Box keycaps a modern and distinct appearance.
- Typing Feel: The sharp edges of the keys can provide an interesting tactile experience, and the slightly higher profile offers more key travel.
- Gaming Performance: Some users find that the profile is great for gaming, especially with the tactile feel provided by Kailh Box switches.
Cons:
- Learning Curve: The sharp edges and higher profile may feel strange at first, requiring an adjustment period for typists used to smoother or lower profiles.
- Compatibility Issues: Kailh Box keycaps can sometimes have compatibility issues with certain switches and stabilizers, limiting their use with some builds.
Conclusion
Choosing the right custom keycap profile comes down to personal preference and typing style. Whether you’re after comfort, aesthetics, or performance, each profile offers distinct advantages and disadvantages. If you’re looking for a traditional, tall feel, SA or OEM might be the right choice. If ergonomics and speed are your priorities, Cherry or DSA may better suit your needs. Ultimately, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but experimenting with different profiles can help you find the perfect fit for your keyboard setup.
4o mini
